Project: Gerrymandering

Analyzing Prop 50 and Spatial Voting Data in California

Agenda

  1. Icebreaker
  2. Project Overview
  3. Worksheet
  4. Project Data
  5. Project Worktime

Project Overview

California Votes!

  • Special Election Nov 4th, 2025
  • Only statewide item: Proposition 50

Current Map

Proposed Map

Measures of Partisan Redistricting

Mean-Median Score Suppose we observe an election where the vote share for Republicans in each of \(n\) districts is \(v_1, \ldots, v_N\).

The mean-median score is:

\[ M = \textrm{mean}(v_i) - \textrm{median}(v_i) \]

Measures of Partisan Redistricting

Suppose two parties, A and B. The efficiency gap (EG) favoring party A for a given pattern of votes, is defined as the difference in wasted votes divided by the total number of votes:

\[ EG = \frac{W_B - W_A}{T} \]

Where \(W_B\) is the number of wasted votes by Party B, \(W_A\) is the number of wasted votes by Party A, and \(T\) is the total votes cast.

Research Question

Will adoption of a new district map lead to an increase in partisan advantage relative to 2024?

If so, by how much?

Words of Wisdom

Moon Duchin, from Political Geometry:

Things I Don’t Believe In

  1. Presenting any single number as a metric of fairness
  2. Especially any single number with a prescribed ideal
  3. Redistricting as optimization

Things I Do Believe In

  1. Using quantitative information to tell a qualitative story

Worksheet

20:00

Project Data

Project Data

To measure potential partisan gerrymandering in 2024…

What we need

  • Vote results by district

What we have

  • Vote results by precinct

Source of 2024 Election Data

2024 Statement of Vote (SOV)

Statewide by voting precincts (SVPREC).

Different areas

Data in California exists at several different geographic areas:

In decreasing size…

  1. State
  2. County (also identified by FIPS code)
  3. Congressional District (CDDIST)
  4. Voting Precinct (SVPREC)
  5. Census Block (has demographic data)

Votes are recorded at the precinct level. Precincts are administered by the counties.

Project Worktime

20:00